416-512-2345
Languages We Speak 
If you or a loved one is facing sexual assault charges in Ontario, securing an experienced criminal defence lawyer is critical. A recent decision from the Court of Appeal for Ontario in R. v. S.K., 2025 ONCA 149, highlights the importance of a fair trial and how legal errors can result in a conviction being overturned.
Explore the case of W.W. and how an acquittal can be overturned in sex crime cases.
Appeal Allowed – New Trial Ordered
In this case, the appellant, S.K., was convicted of sexual interference after a jury trial but was not convicted of sexual assault due to a mistrial. The complainant, a family member, alleged ongoing sexual abuse from the ages of 8 to 18. S.K. denied all allegations and represented himself at trial.
The Court of Appeal found that the trial was unfair due to improper statements made by the Crown prosecutor during closing arguments. Specifically, the Crown argued that S.K.’s lack of romantic relationships with women since 2008–2009 was a motive for the alleged offences. The trial judge failed to correct this improper argument, which may have unfairly influenced the jury’s decision.
Key Reasons the Conviction Was Overturned
- Irrelevant and Prejudicial Reasoning – The Crown suggested that the accused’s lack of relationships with women made him more likely to commit a sexual offence. The Court ruled that this was an improper and unfair assumption that had no bearing on the facts.
- Failure to Provide a Fair Trial – The trial judge included the Crown’s improper argument in jury instructions, further elevating the unfair suggestion that the accused had a motive based on his personal life.
- No Opportunity for Defence – Since S.K. represented himself, he was not given a proper chance to challenge the Crown’s claims about motive.
Due to these errors, the Court of Appeal set aside the conviction and ordered a new trial.
Why This Matters If You’re Facing Sex Crime Charges
This case demonstrates that even if a jury convicts, legal errors during the trial can lead to a successful appeal. If you have been charged with sexual interference, sexual assault, or a related offence, an experienced criminal defence lawyer can ensure your rights are protected and fight for a fair trial.
Defending Against Sexual Assault Allegations
Sexual assault cases are complex and highly sensitive. The consequences of a conviction are severe, including jail time, sex offender registration, and lasting damage to your reputation. A strong defence strategy may involve:
✔️ Challenging unreliable evidence
✔️ Cross-examining witnesses effectively
✔️ Identifying improper Crown arguments
✔️ Ensuring a fair and impartial trial
If you are accused of sexual interference or sexual assault in Ontario, do not face these charges alone. Contact a skilled criminal defence lawyer immediately to protect your future.
